Victor Tan.
Two hundred and seventy-three dated slips hung beneath the name.
Martin did not touch the photograph. His torch divided his father's young face into light and shadow. Three pairs of tweezers showed in the pocket of Victor's dark-blue Wing On apron. Martin remembered a man who left for work in white shirts. Nothing in his memory connected Victor to this room.
“How long did he work here?”
The watchmaker drew the curtain over the wall.
“You're not ready to ask about that picture.”
“You chose to show it to me.”
“Seeing isn't passing,” the man said. “Give someone a photograph and a familiar name, and they'll build you a childhood.”
Evelyn switched off her torch. Darkness held for a moment before the ticking from the front room found its way through the cork walls.
“You think his memories are false?” she asked.
“I think people are most suggestible when they've just found the answer they wanted.”
He led them back to the scarred tables. The other visitors were returning their evidence to narrow cabinets. Nobody gathered to watch Martin. Nobody seemed surprised that Victor Tan had a son.
The watchmaker divided a blank form into three columns.
Physical evidence.
Independent testimony.
Bodily habit.
“If all three point to the same relationship, we hold it provisionally,” he said. “If one conflicts, suspicion does not become memory.”
Martin studied the first column. “Who selects the test?”
“Someone who doesn't know your answer.”
The schoolboy brought nine grey envelopes from a locked cabinet. Only numbers marked their fronts. He set them down and left; even the person administering the objects did not know their owners.
“Are you testing your father?” the watchmaker asked.
“No. I'm testing the hand at the edge of the family photograph.”
Victor's portrait proved that Victor had once stood inside Wing On. The child's fingers reaching into Martin's family picture were the relationship every official record refused to explain.
The watchmaker turned to Evelyn. “What did you tell him before tonight?”
“Only the name he showed me. Clara Tan.”
“Do you believe she was his sister?”
“I believe he's searching for someone described as his sister.”
Her answer did not give Martin an extra vote.
The first test began.
Three envelopes held objects Victor had left with the Society. Three belonged to other missing people. Three more were decoys bought from a flea market. Martin could not see the labels. He had to explain how each thing connected to him.
The first contained a corroded contact from a two-tone doorbell. Martin knew moisture delayed its lower note. He could not count that as proof; the telephone spectrum had already reminded him.
The second contained a blue-black fountain pen with bite marks inside its cap. Victor never chewed pens. Martin put it with the unrelated objects.
Inside the third was a faded drinks receipt: black coffee without sugar and barley water, less sweet. Saturday afternoon, twenty years earlier. The purchaser field contained half of the surname Tan.
Martin's finger stopped over LESS SWEET.
He could summon no shop, no table, no person waiting for the second drink. The grease and folds on the paper were unfamiliar. Still, he knew the two lines belonged to one purchase.
“Why?” the watchmaker asked.
“The fold crosses both items. Someone put the whole receipt in one pocket.”
“That proves one payment.”
“There's an impression from a straw in the lower corner. Whoever took the receipt had already opened one.”
“And none of that identifies the drinker.”
Martin left the receipt in the undecided pile.
After all nine objects, he accepted only the doorbell contact as connected to Victor. He rejected five and reserved judgement on three. One was a pale-blue hair clip matching the painted fingernail in the photograph. He still refused it.
“A colour isn't a relationship,” he said.
The undecided group also contained a child's watch and half an amusement-park ticket. CLARA was engraved on the watch, but by machine. It could have been produced after Martin learned the name. The ticket covered two children, but its purchasing account was blank. It could have belonged to any family.
The watchmaker tested him. “The name isn't enough?”
“If someone wanted to give me a sister, that's the easiest object to prepare.”
Martin returned to the doorbell contact. The solder showed the margins of two repairs. The later one touched only the damp lower plate. Victor had taken the housing apart more than once, and Martin's hands knew a detail older than last night's spectrum: when passing the screwdriver, Victor made him hold the insulated handle and stay away from the blackened copper.
Martin closed his eyes and repeated the movement. His right hand avoided the contact and laid a flat-head screwdriver sideways. When he looked again, he had unconsciously moved the tool on the tray into that exact position.
It connected the bell to Martin. It did not establish a fourth person in the flat. An object could preserve a question. It could not fill the blank with a sister.
The watchmaker made his first mark on the form.
Physical evidence had not proved Clara existed. It preserved an unexplained grouping: Victor Tan, unsweetened black coffee, less-sweet barley water, and a receipt that might have carried both from the same afternoon.
The second test was testimony.
The room lights dimmed. The watchmaker played four sealed recordings. The witnesses had never met and did not know Martin would hear them.
A former newspaper seller from the shop next door remembered Victor bringing a boy on Saturdays. The boy sat near the entrance and watched the repairs.
A retired bus driver remembered two children, one taller than the other. The boy jumped down first. The girl needed someone to hold her hand.
The third witness remembered only the girl. She loved bright pink syrup, wore a red raincoat and had a burn across her left hand.
“That isn't her,” Martin said at once.
“You don't have a clear memory of her,” the watchmaker said.
“The raincoat came from Hannah's case. The burn belongs to the Melissa record we heard tonight. The sweet drink contradicts the receipt. Somebody assembled this.”
The Society had fabricated the third statement from details spoken in the room. It tested whether Martin would accept anything in exchange for a sister.
The fourth recording belonged to a woman who had worked at a drinks stall. She remembered a boy ordering “less sweet” for his younger sister. The girl always complained, then added half a spoon of sugar herself.
“Did she remember a name?” Martin asked.
“No.”
“A photograph?”
“None.”
Two independent voices supported the presence of two children. The same rumour could still have contaminated both. The watchmaker drew only half a circle in the testimony column.
“The third layer won't ask what you remember,” he said. “It watches what you do before you have time to explain.”
The others returned to their places. Three tables became one long surface. Twelve chairs surrounded it, and one remained empty. Nobody told Martin whom the empty place represented.
The watchmaker handed the old receipt to a runner outside and asked for the same order. While they waited, Martin had to discuss Hannah's encrypted file with Evelyn. He was not allowed to watch the vacant chair.
Ten minutes later, a plastic bag came through the narrow door. Black coffee, tea, canned drinks and barley water were placed at random. There was one drink more than there were people.
Martin was describing the transfer valve when his right hand moved the barley water to the empty place.
He did not notice.
Evelyn said nothing. She watched him take a straw, open its paper and turn the pointed end towards the left. Then he pushed the sugar jar within reach of the empty chair.
“Who's that for?” the watchmaker asked.
Martin's hand remained on the jar.
The chair held no face, no height, no age. He could not assemble a girl inside Wing On, however hard he tried. All he saw were four fingers at the edge of his mother's photograph.
His body knew the straw belonged on the left.
It knew she disliked sweet drinks but wanted to decide for herself whether to add sugar.
“Clara,” he said.
No image returned. The response was an old act of care repeated often enough to outlast the story attached to it.
The watchmaker did not score him yet. He cleared the table, changed the cloth and sent Martin into the corridor for five minutes. When Martin returned, there were eleven chairs instead of twelve. The barley water had been poured into an unmarked paper cup. The sugar sat at the opposite end.
This time they discussed Victor's photograph. Martin was answering a third question when his left hand passed over two identical drinks and tested one for temperature. He set the cooler cup on his right, measured half a spoon of sugar, and left it on the lid rather than mixing it in.
“Why that cup?” Evelyn asked.
“She doesn't like the ice melting too fast.”
Only after speaking did Martin hear the pronoun. The girl still had no face. He had only the physical fragment of a summer afternoon: a wet plastic cup wrapped in tissue; someone complaining that he had bent the straw, then snatching it away to pierce the lid herself.
The memory had no beginning and no voice. It might be old experience. It might have been produced by testimony and the drink in front of him.
Martin did not write it as fact. He recorded only what his hands had done and placed a question mark after SHE DOESN'T LIKE THE ICE MELTING TOO FAST.
The watchmaker completed the circle in the third column.
Object, testimony, habit. All three retained the same shape; none could independently establish who Clara Tan was. The Society entered the relationship as HIGH PROBABILITY—INCOMPLETE.
“Because his mother didn't come?” Evelyn asked.
“Because the witness closest to the relationship is absent.”
Martin looked at the drink before the empty chair. He had decided his mother would not come. Now her missing testimony was precisely what the test lacked. He could not blame the system for that gap.
“Did I pass?”
“You passed the part where you refuse a convenient lie,” the watchmaker said. “That isn't the same as proving the truth.”
He collected the test form and left the barley water untouched. Condensation gathered in a ring on the table.
“Why three layers?” Evelyn asked.
“Data can be revised. Testimony infects other testimony. The body learns new habits,” the watchmaker said. “All three fail. They fail at different speeds, which gives them a chance to catch one another.”
“And if all three are wrong?”
“We don't conclude.”
It was not an answer the Municipal Data Consistency Center permitted. Every case had to close as true, false, duplicate or invalid. The Missing Page Society allowed a relationship to remain unresolved, paying for that uncertainty by repeating the work every day.
The watchmaker removed a shallow wooden box from beneath the counter.
Its lid carried the open-book stamp. A deep line beside the keyhole had the same length and pressure as the crossbar Victor added to every handwritten 7.
“My father left this?”
“Victor left us many answers,” the watchmaker said. “He also left methods for distrusting them.”
The box held no keepsakes. It contained a stack of test forms yellowed with age. Their columns matched the one Martin had just completed: object, testimony, bodily habit.
The form on top was dated twenty years earlier.
Black ink covered the name of the relationship under examination. The three findings read RELATIONSHIP PRESENT, TESTIMONY IN CONFLICT and HABIT PERSISTS. The final status did not say incomplete.
It said PROCEDURE COMPLETE.
Martin turned the page over.
A child's medical identification band had been fixed to the back. The plastic had hardened, but the name remained legible.
Martin Tan.
Age: eleven.
Procedure: relational memory restructuring.
Outcome: complete.
The test he had passed tonight had been administered to him once before.
Loading comments…